Wednesday, September 26, 2012

The Unexamined Life/ The Modern Gadfly

"The unexamined life is not worth living." - Socrates

             In my opinion, our ability to analyze ourselves and our surroundings is what separates us from animals. Dogs, for example, perceive their environment and maybe even themselves, but they lack the mental capacity for introspection and questioning. They seek to satisfy their basic needs, and are creatures driven purely by instinct. People should be better than that, because basing life on our primal natures would lead to nothing but fatal competition and greed. As an illustration of that point, check out America. Capitalism is a crude system because it can only harness the inherent desire of individuals to provide for themselves, rather than overcoming those selfish elements of our essence for the common good. Yet, the open market/perfect competition economic model is hailed as the best to date. We have achieved a relative success; but at what cost? War? Suffering? Worldwide exploitation of indigenous peoples?
            
            Just as a nation or a society, when an individual lives an unexamined life, he is something of a permanently benched player, one that can only follow the course of the game without exerting any influence on its outcome. I believe that people should be more than driftwood in the raging current of life's river, so that they can look back on something more than an existence, and reflect upon a multitude of informed, conscious choices that they made with the purpose of reaching their goals. Each life should be examined because society tends to dictate the direction of people that do not know enough about themselves to forge their own path. At the moment, I don't think that I have enough certainty in my own wants and needs to set long-term life goals, but through my recognition of this fact, I have identified a problem that must be solved in order to get me on the right track. If, through deep thought, I can achieve greater self-knowledge, I will be able to make my own way in the world. Eventually, my godless and faithless self will be prepared to face the trials of life, which should only be approached with a clear sense of direction, as they tend to crush the half-baked hopes and dreams of late adolescence.

            As for a modern "gadfly", I don't really have a clear example in mind. I don't watch TV and am not very well informed on the names of insightful celebrities and witty political commentators. Since I can't cite a particular person, I'll make the claim that the entire field of mainstream, televised political commentary can, in an odd way, be likened to Socrates. Just as the great philosopher questioned the views and principles of the powerful figures he approached, so do the political commentators of the modern day. Political commentators are also like modern "gadflies" in that it is their job to get in other peoples' business and then sardonically comment on it (in front of an audience, like Socrates, no less.) It may seem as though political commentary does not really bring those commented upon to new self-knowledge, but I bet televised remarks about political figures are usually heard by said political figures, which means that they would have the chance to reflect on them and potentially get insight from the "gadfly."

2 comments:

  1. I don't necessarily disagree with your characterization of these political commentators, but if you say that you don't watch television, from where does your impression come? I don't doubt that there are some people in this line of work that are far more intelligent than others, to say the least. That being the case, how do you distinguish them from the gadflies who are nothing but talking heads?

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is the exact problem with modern gadflies. The speed and usefulness and popularity of media makes it easy for there to be so many commentators that they become indistinguishable (to say the least). We hear of Socrates being the sole case of gadfly in the world he lived in, but we ourselves are constantly pummeled by them on radio, TV, the internet and any other source of media. Therefore I honestly don't believe that political figures can gain anything from even the real gadflies who aren't just "talking heads" because they literally are TIRED OF HEARING IT, the same thing from so many people, both commentators doing their jobs and uneducated (or educated?) citizens of this country, these pseudo-gadflies.

    ReplyDelete